| □ | 38 | Amy Madison | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 86 | Angel | Character | Rare |
| □ | 87 | Angelus | Character | Rare |
| □ | 88 | Angelus | Character | Rare |
| □ | 39 | Billy Fordham | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 89 | Buffy Summers | Character | Rare |
| □ | 40 | Cameron Walker | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 5 | Coach Marin | Character | Common |
| □ | 90 | Collin, The Anointed One | Character | Rare |
| □ | 91 | Cordelia | Character | Rare |
| □ | 6 | Dalton | Character | Common |
| □ | 41 | Der Kindestod | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 42 | Doug Perren | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 92 | Drusilla | Character | Rare |
| □ | 42 | Ethan Rayne | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 44 | Gill Monster | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 93 | Jenny Calendar | Character | Rare |
| □ | 45 | Kendra | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 94 | Kendra | Character | Rare |
| □ | Preview 3 | Lily | Character | Rare |
| □ | P2 | Octarus* | Character | Promo |
| □ | 46 | Oz | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 47 | Oz | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 95 | Principal Snyder | Character | Rare |
| □ | 96 | Rupert Giles | Character | Rare |
| □ | 97 | Spike | Character | Rare |
| □ | 48 | Ted Buchanan | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 98 | The Judge | Character | Rare |
| □ | 99 | The Master | Character | Rare |
| □ | 100 | Uncle Enyos | Character | Rare |
| □ | P3 | Whistler | Character | Promo |
| □ | 101 | Willow Rosenberg | Character | Rare |
| □ | 49 | Willy | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 50 | Xander | Character | Uncommon |
| □ | 4 | Death Stalks the Dream | Evil Challenge | Common |
| □ | 2 | Die Young and Stay Pretty | Evil Challenge | Common |
| □ | 83 | It's the End of the World as We Know It | Evil Challenge | Rare |
| □ | 84 | Jigsaw Judge | Evil Challenge | Rare |
| □ | P1 | My Bloody Valentine | Evil Challenge | Promo |
| □ | 35 | New Dad in Town | Evil Challenge | Uncommon |
| □ | 85 | Ritual of Eligor | Evil Challenge | Rare |
| □ | 36 | Something Fishy This Way Comes | Evil Challenge | Uncommon |
| □ | 33 | A Soul's Revenge | Good Challenge | Uncommon |
| □ | 1 | Bad Eggs | Good Challenge | Common |
| □ | 34 | An American Werewolf in Sunnydale | Good Challenge | Uncommon |
| □ | 3 | Love Sucks | Good Challenge | Common |
| □ | 37 | The Dark Age | Good Challenge | Uncommon |
| □ | 11 | Body of a Dead Cheerleader | Item | Common |
| □ | 104 | Claddagh Ring | Item | Rare |
| □ | 105 | Disembodied Arm | Item | Rare |
| □ | P6 | Mark of Eyghon | Item | Promo |
| □ | 106 | Mr. Pointy | Item | Rare |
| □ | 56 | Mummy's Seal | Item | Uncommon |
| □ | 107 | Orb of Thesulah | Item | Rare |
| □ | 108 | Rocket Launcher | Item | Rare |
| □ | 109 | Silver Locket | Item | Rare |
| □ | 15 | Spike's Car | Item | Common |
| □ | 57 | Tattoo Remover (Acid)* | Item | Uncommon |
| □ | 17 | Tweed Mail | Item | Common |
| □ | 58 | Video Camera | Item | Uncommon |
| □ | 54 | Black Lagoon Aromatherapy | Skill | Uncommon |
| □ | 55 | Diana's Touch | Skill | Uncommon |
| □ | P5 | Everyday Vamp Hijinks | Skill | Promo |
| □ | 12 | Gypsy Curse | Skill | Common |
| □ | 13 | Machiavellian Ingenuity | Skill | Common |
| □ | 119 | Ritual of Acathla | Skill | Rare |
| □ | 14 | Ritual of Restoration | Skill | Common |
| □ | 16 | The Look | Skill | Common |
| □ | 59 | Wavering Power | Skill | Uncommon |
| □ | 60 | Weapons Expert | Skill | Uncommon |
| □ | 110 | What Doesn't Kill You... | Skill | Rare |
| □ | 18 | Wisdom | Skill | Common |
| □ | 125 | Angelus | Essence | Uncommon |
| □ | 124 | Cordelia | Essence | Uncommon |
| □ | 123 | Kendra | Essence | Uncommon |
| □ | 122 | Xander | Essence | Uncommon |
| □ | 22 | A Lover's Gift | Action | Common |
| □ | 23 | Angry Mob | Action | Common |
| □ | 24 | Anywhere But Here | Action | Common |
| □ | P8 | Attack of the Stunt Doubles | Action | Promo |
| □ | 64 | Bad Alcohol | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 65 | Blind Panic | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 63 | B.O. | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 66 | Box of Goodies | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 113 | Breaking Free | Action | Rare |
| □ | P9 | Candy Tactics | Action | Promo |
| □ | 67 | Choke Hold | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 68 | Competition Appraisal* | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 114 | Concealed Weapon | Action | Rare |
| □ | 25 | Confrontation* | Action | Common |
| □ | 26 | Cut From the Same Cloth* | Action | Common |
| □ | 69 | Desperate Maneuvers | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 70 | Fatal Recovery | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 115 | Finding Your Destiny | Action | Rare |
| □ | 116 | Flashy Swordfight | Action | Rare |
| □ | Preview 1 | Forceful Persuasion | Action | Common |
| □ | 71 | Gathering of Scoobies | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 27 | Going Goth | Action | Common |
| □ | 72 | Grounded | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 73 | Henchmen-R-Us | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 80 | Here's How You Eat It | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 74 | Homeric Insensitivity | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 28 | Hot Sheets | Action | Common |
| □ | 75 | Hypnotic Grasp | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 117 | Hypnotism | Action | Rare |
| □ | 76 | Master of Ceremonies | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 77 | No More Soul* | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 78 | Slay Industries | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 29 | Soda Machine Raid | Action | Common |
| □ | 79 | Surprise! | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | P10 | To Be Continued... | Action | Promo |
| □ | 30 | Total Lecture Overload* | Action | Common |
| □ | 31 | Tremors | Action | Common |
| □ | 32 | Unwelcome Surprise | Action | Common |
| □ | 118 | Vampiric Expertise | Action | Rare |
| □ | 81 | Visions | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 82 | What Comes Around... | Action | Uncommon |
| □ | 121 | Wrath of Angelus | Action | Ultra Rare |
| □ | 7 | 50's Time Capsule | Location | Common |
| □ | 51 | Army Base | Location | Uncommon |
| □ | 8 | Dragon's Cove Magic Shop | Location | Common |
| □ | 9 | Ethan's Costume Shop | Location | Common |
| □ | 102 | Natural History Museum | Location | Rare |
| □ | P4 | Rupert's Pad | Location | Promo |
| □ | 120 | St. du Lac Mausoleum | Location | Ultra Rare |
| □ | 52 | Sunnydale City Morgue | Location | Uncommon |
| □ | 10 | Sunset Club | Location | Common |
| □ | 103 | Vampire Mansion | Location | Rare |
| □ | 53 | Willy's Bar | Location | Uncommon |
| □ | 61 | A Fervent Wish* | Event | Uncommon |
| □ | 111 | Death | Event | Rare |
| □ | P7 | Full Moon* | Event | Promo |
| □ | Preview 2 | Home Again | Event | Uncommon |
| □ | 62 | Immolation-o-gram | Event | Uncommon |
| □ | 19 | PDA | Event | Common |
| □ | 112 | Slayer's Burden | Event | Rare |
| □ | 20 | Something Weird | Event | Common |
| □ | 21 | The Plan | Event | Common |
